“Andrew Constance has no local government employment experience.”
Verdict
✅TrueConfidence
Solid evidence with some gaps or secondary sources.
What We Found
The claim that Andrew Constance has no local government employment experience is accurate. His professional background consists of 18 years as a Member of the New South Wales Legislative Assembly and various state ministerial roles, but he has not previously held a position within local government administration.
Evidence
The claim made by Fiona Phillips, the Member for Gilmore, is factually accurate regarding Andrew Constance's professional history. An examination of Mr. Constance's career, as documented in his professional profiles and media reports, confirms that his public sector experience is exclusively at the state level. He served as the Member for Bega in the New South Wales Parliament from 2003 to 2021 and held several ministerial portfolios, including Transport and Roads, Finance and Services, and Treasurer. There is no record of him holding an administrative or employment role within a local government council prior to his appointment as the CEO of Shoalhaven City Council in October 2025. Multiple independent sources, including news reports covering the controversy surrounding his appointment, explicitly state that he lacks direct local government employment experience.
What's Missing or Misleading
While the claim regarding his lack of local government experience is true, it is important to note that Mr. Constance's supporters and his own public statements emphasize his 18 years of state-level government experience, including budget management and infrastructure delivery, as transferable skills for the CEO role.
Sources Reviewed (4)
Andrew Constance's new job as council CEO 'smacks of political bastardry', MP claims
Andrew Constance's new job as council CEO 'smacks of political bastardry', MP claims
Primary Sources
Members of the Legislative Assembly - The Hon. Andrew James CONSTANCE
This fact-check was generated by automated AI research. It has not been examined by a human reviewer.